August 6, 2011
The Chairman
Press Council of India
New Delhi
Dear Sir,
We would like to bring to your attention an article
published in DNA, dated July 16, 2011, by Dr Subramanian
Swamy, titled `How to wipe out Islamic Terror’. The piece
was published three days after the Mumbai bomb blasts.
We believe that the piece violates the Press Council
guidelines on communal issues, issued in 2010, specially :
i) ``News, views or comments relating to communal or
religious disputes/clashes shall be published after proper
verification of facts and presented with due caution and
restraint in a manner which is conducive to the creation of
an atmosphere congenial to communal harmony, amity and
peace…..writing about the incident in a style which is
likely to inflame passions, aggravate the tension, or
accentuate the strained relations between the
communities/religious groups concerned, or which has a
potential to exacerbate the trouble, shall be avoided.
ii) ``Journalists and columnists owe a very special
responsibility to their country in promoting communal peace
and amity. Their writings are not a mere reflection of
their own feelings but help to large extent in moulding the
feelings and sentiments of the society at large. It is,
therefore, of utmost importance that they use their pen
with circumspection and restraint.
iii)``…a heavy responsibility devolves on the author of
opinion articles. The author has to ensure that not only are
his or her analysis free from any personal preferences,
prejudices or notions, but also they are based on verified,
accurate and established facts and do not tend to foment
disharmony or enmity between castes, communities and
races.’’
At a sensitive time like this, Dr Swamy's diatribe can only
serve to inflame passions against an entire community. In
the wake of angry rejoinders to the article, the editor of
DNA wrote that Dr Swamy's views were published in the
``spirit of not denying space to different points of view.''
But a point of view expressed in terms that constitute an
offence under IPC Sec 153-A (promoting communal enmity),
scarcely deserved space in a responsible newspaper.
We request the Press Council to please examine the matter
and take appropriate action.
Signed:
1. Sukla Sen, Peace activist, Mumbai
2. Daniel Mazagaonkar, Sarvodaya activist,
Mumbai
3. Ammu Joseph, senior journalist, Bangalore
4. Suhasini Ali, trade union leader, Kanpur
5. Manisha Sethi, Jamia Teachers Solidarity
Association, Delhi
6. Dhirendra Sharma Centre for Science Policy
7. Rohini Hensman, researcher & human rights
activist, Mumbai
8. Ajay Shaw, poet, mumbai
9. Kamayani Bali Mahabal, human rights activist,
mumbai
10. Kaveri Rajaraman, post-doc researcher, IISC,
Banglaore
11. Vrijendra, human rights activist, Mumbai,
12. S Seshan, teacher, Mumbai
13. Sumathi Sudhakar Children's Writer and
Publisher, Chennai
14. Jyoti Punwani, journalist, Mumbai
15. M A Siraj, journalist, Bangalore
16. Md Ali, journalist, Delhi
17. Saurav Datta, advocate & law lecturer, Mumbai
18. A J Jawad, Advocate, Madras.
19. Zafarullah Khan, Advocate , Chennai
20. Ajit Eapen, human rights activist, Mumbai
21. Dr Zaheer Ahmed Sayeed, chennai
22. Anil Bhatia,former Banker, Mumbai
23. Ghulam Mohiyuddin, secular activist
24. Shahidur Rashid Talukdar USA
25. Shrikumar Poddar- NRISAHI
(Non Resident Indians for Secular and Harmonious India)
26. George Abraham-ditto
27. Mohammad Imran-ditto
28. Armana Ishaque—ditto
29. Md Mansoor Khan Business-hirer, Secunderabad
30. Musab Iqbal, Journalist, New Delhi
Attached:
Letter to the Editor. DNA, Mumbai
Article by Subramanian Swamy
DECLARATION
“I declare to the best of my knowledge and belief that I
have placed all the relevant facts before the Council and
that no proceedings are pending in any court of law in
respect of any matter alleged in the complaint. I will
notify the Council forthwith if during the pendency of the
inquiry before the Council any matter alleged in the
complaint becomes the subject matter of any proceedings in a
court of law".
Signed:
1. Sukla Sen, Peace activist, Mumbai
2. Daniel Mazagaonkar, Sarvodaya activist,
Mumbai
3. Ammu Joseph, senior journalist, Bangalore
4. Suhasini Ali, trade union leader, Kanpur
5. Manisha Sethi, Jamia Teachers Solidarity
Association, Delhi
6. Dhirendra Sharma Centre for Science Policy,
Dehradun
7. Rohini Hensman, researcher & human rights
activist, Mumbai
8. Ajay Shaw, poet, mumbai
9. Kamayani Bali Mahabal, human rights activist,
mumbai
10. Kaveri Rajaraman, post-doc researcher, IISC,
Banglaore
11. Vrijendra, human rights activist, Mumbai,
12. S Seshan, teacher, Mumbai
13. Sumathi Sudhakar Children's Writer and
Publisher, Chennai
14. Jyoti Punwani, journalist, Mumbai
15. M A Siraj, journalist, Bangalore
16. Md Ali, journalist, Delhi
17. Saurav Datta, advocate & law lecturer, Mumbai
18. A J Jawad, Advocate, Madras.
19. Zafarullah Khan, Advocate , Chennai
20. Ajit Eapen, human rights activist, Mumbai
21. Dr Zaheer Ahmed Sayeed, chennai
22. Anil Bhatia,former Banker, Mumbai
23. Ghulam Mohiyuddin, secular activist
24. Shahidur Rashid Talukdar USA
25. Shrikumar Poddar USA- NRISAHI (Non Resident
Indians for Secular
and Harmonious India)
26. George Abraham- NRISAHI
27. Mohammad Imran- NRISAHI
28. Armana Ishaque- NRISAHI
29. Md Mansoor Khan Business-hirer, Secunderabad
30. Musab Iqbal, Journalist, New Delhi
August 6, 2011