Punished for ‘offending the Hindu way of life’
On March 13, 2005 two residents of Mooluru village near
Kapu, Udupi were stripped, paraded naked and brutally assaulted in front
of an audience of more than 100 people by fascist Hindu right wing forces.
The public humiliation continued with the publication of a photograph, for
which they were forced to pose, on the front pages of leading Kannada
newspapers.
Hajabba (60) and his son, Hasanabba (29), were being
‘punished’ by Hindu Yuva Sena (HYS) members for offending ‘the Hindu way
of life’. In what appears to be a pre-planned attack, HYS activists
accosted Hajabba as he arrived to transport a calf, dragged him to the Adi
Udupi helipad near Udupi town and continued their assault even as a crowd
gathered. Hasanabba, who went in search of his father, was also waylaid
and publicly humiliated. Both Hajabba and Hasanabba suffered serious
injuries – Hasanabba’s leg was fractured while Hajabba’s spine was damaged
– and remained in hospital for several weeks. There is no accounting for
the mental trauma that they underwent at the time. A press photographer
summoned at the end of this barbaric display of strength was asked to
‘show all the Muslims what would happen if they didn’t listen to Hindus’.
"We were horrified that such an incident took place in the
first place. What made it worse was that there was a silent crowd watching
the spectacle as it unfolded," said KL Ashok, convenor, Karnataka Komu
Souharda Vedike. "This silent support, the fear immobilising people is
what sustains communal forces."
Police: clothed in saffron
It can come as no surprise that police action at the time
of the incident was hugely inadequate and delayed. The location where the
incident took place falls under the Adi Udupi police station limits. Local
police officers failed to take cognisance of the crime despite wide
coverage of the incident in the press. It was only when the issue was
raised in the Legislative Assembly by MLAs Shriram Reddy (CPI-M) and
Jayaprakash Reddy (Independent), and the Congress government demanded
answers from the police, that they sprung into action. The Udupi
superintendent of police at the time, S. Murugan, was intimated of the
incident through a telephone call from the then chief minister, Dharam
Singh, enquiring about the progress made in arresting the accused. Several
senior police officers, including Murugan, were criticised severally for
their lapses as well as for their alleged pro-Hindutva leanings.
One of the reasons cited by the police for investigational
delays and police lapses was jurisdictional dispute. The sub-inspector of
Malpe police station at the time, CD Nagaraj, did not follow up the
stripping incident because it started at Moodabettu, an area under the
Udupi town police station.
"Jurisdictional dispute is unacceptable as an excuse. The
CrPC (Criminal Procedure Code) clearly stipulates that although the place
where an offence is initially committed is important, no officer can shrug
his responsibility on the plea that it falls beyond his jurisdiction
limits. In any case, both Malpe and Udupi town police stations fall under
the responsibility of the Udupi circle inspector of police. What was his
excuse?" asked Sheela Ramanathan, advocate, Human Rights Law Network.
Subsequently, both the Udupi circle inspector, Praveen
Naik, and Malpe sub-inspector, Nagaraj, were placed under suspension.
‘Communal violence will be countered on the streets’
Within a week of the incident, the Karnataka Komu Souharda
Vedike, an aggressive secularist force bringing together all progressive
movements in the state in a broad alliance, organised a massive rally and
dharna in front of the then Udupi deputy commissioner’s office. With the
perspective that communalism was not merely an onslaught on religion but
rather an attack on democratic processes (defining aggressive secularism
thus), the Vedike sought to strongly condemn communal forces and to demand
stringent actions against the culprits involved. Over 15,000 people
marched on the streets to demand that the deputy commissioner ban
"reactionary organisations" indulging in violence and that action should
be taken against the police personnel who support "reactionary forces".
Protestors included the seer of Murugarajendra Math (Chitradurga),
the Sri Revannasiddeshwara Math (Dharwad) seer Basavaraja Devaru, Sanath
Kumar Belagali, KL Ashok, Kalkuli Vittal Hegde, KM Sharief and Annar
Sadath.
"The protest was important to show sangh parivar forces
that the communal violence being inflicted by them will be countered on
the streets," observed Gauri Lankesh, editor, Lankesh, and state
committee member, Karnataka Komu Souharda Vedike. "We wanted to tell
society and the state that there are people who will gather to question
and condemn the hatred being infused by Hindu right-wingers. We stand for
communal harmony and we will defend it in this state."
Shamed into action by the number of people who had
gathered on the streets and the growing anger over police inaction on the
issue, the state handed over investigations into the incident to the Corps
of Detectives (CoD) in May 2005. In the preliminary report filed by the
CoD, key Hindu Yuva Sena leaders, including Yashpal Suvarna, have been
held responsible for the stripping and assault case. A charge sheet was
filed against Suvarna in the Udupi town police station.
Riding the cow: communal agendas gain foothold
Although cow slaughter is banned in Karnataka only in
particular instances under the Prevention of Cow Slaughter and Cattle
Preservation Act, there is no law regulating or banning the transportation
of cows. Sangh parivar forces constantly use this law to implement their
communal agendas and forcibly block transportation of all cattle. The fact
that a significant number of livestock traders are Muslim provides
sufficient grounds for Hindu communal forces to persecute Muslims and
further their communal agenda.
It is pertinent to note that stringent official and
unofficial actions against the transportation of cattle gained ground
after the NDA assumed power at the Centre in 1999. For the record, police
officials say that incidents where Hindu organisations confront people
transporting cattle and assault them "are viewed seriously" and cases were
booked against people indulging in such acts. Similarly, "a serious view
is taken of people transporting cattle, especially cows, in violation of
laws".
At an all party peace committee meeting held at the Udupi
deputy commissioner’s office on March 22, 2005 following the Adi Udupi
incident, the then deputy commissioner, T. Sham Bhatt announced: "The
district administration will provide information about Cow Slaughter
Prohibition Act to the public. If there is any violation of law,
information should be given to the departments concerned. No one should
take law into his hands. If the officials did not respond, then superior
officials should be approached."
These are statements that have remained on paper. More
than a year after the Adi Udupi incident, the state has chosen to
recognise Suvarna’s contribution in this specific case by awarding him a
nomination to the town council even as it continues to turn a blind eye to
the increasing number of attacks by sangh parivar forces on Muslim
livestock traders across the Dakshina Kannada district.
"It is crucial to not only condemn police inaction when
attacks on livestock traders take place but more importantly, we need to
protest against the Brahminical values being forced down on us through
official and unofficial legislations," observed Vasu HV, convenor,
Bangalore unit, Karnataka Komu Souharda Vedike. "After all, beef has been
the traditional diet of not only Muslims but entire sections of the Dalit
population as well. We don’t consider Dalits to be Hindus but according to
the sangh parivar’s own definitions, Dalits are Hindus too. So by their
own logic, where is the question of beef-eating offending the Hindu way of
life?"
The Adi Udupi incident has exposed not only the anti-human
face of the sangh parivar but the communal nature of the current BJP-JD
(S) coalition government. There can be no doubt that the government’s
decision to nominate Yashpal Suvarna for the post of councillor on the
basis of a recommendation by medical education minister, Dr VS Acharya,
and Udupi BJP MLA, K. Raghupathy Bhatta, is but a direct endorsement of
Suvarna’s crimes.
Karnataka Komu Souharda Vedike
.