Pallbearers
of Justice
In
immediate response to the agony and outrage generated by the massacre of
innocent citizens post demolition of the Babri Masjid at Ayodhya in
1992-1993, the Indian People’s Human Rights Commission set up the people’s
tribunal to investigate the violence and collect evidence. Justices SM
Daud and Hosbet Suresh conducted the inquiry.
Between
February and June 1993, the tribunal visited affected areas and recorded
evidence, ably assisted by activists and organisations across Bombay. The
tribunal collected 2046 statements in all, apart from collecting reports
from journalists, activists and organisations. The report, People’s
Verdict released in July 1993 apart from making valuable
recommendations, identified accused rioters and 75 policemen guilty of
criminal negligence, named by witnesses.
The state
government announced the constitution of a judicial commission of inquiry
through a sitting judge of the Bombay High Court, Justice BN Srikrishna to
investigate the violence on January 17 though the Commission was formally
established on January 25, 1993. On February 16, 1998 the Judge submitted
his report that identified the Shiv Sena, its chief Bal Thackeray and
their political allies, the BharatiyaJanata Party (BJP) as those
responsible for the conspiracy to commit violence, specifically naming 31
policemen guilty of criminal negligence who deserved to be prosecuted.
Though the SS-BJP government was voted out of power in 1999 in Maharashtra,
few of the recommendations of the Commission have been implemented by the
Congress-NCP governments that have governed since.
On January
23, 1996 soon after riding to power in the state, the SS-BJP combine had
scrapped the Justice BN Srikrishna Commission. Outraged protests by
citizens beginning with a dharna by several organisations at
HutatmaChowk on January 30, 1996 and a petition filed by the People’s
Union for Civil Liberties led the Central government under Prime Minister
Vajpayee to re-instate it on May 28, 1996.
The report
of the Commission remains a sorry testimony to the violence that engulfed
Bombay. Sabrang was proud to publish the report in
two editions within weeks of the report being submitted to the state
government in 1998 and making it available at affordable prices. This was
possible due to the individual contributions of Sabrang patrons.
The non prosecution of those found guilty has ensured not just their
impunity but has contributed to the stranglehold of the Shiv Sena’s –and
sister organisations -- brand of violence and intimidation over Mumbai.